This week’s Stargate Universe (the fourth episode) was the last one I’ll be watching. As a longtime Stargate SG-1 and Stargate Atlantis fan, I was SOOO excited when the creators decided to make a third series. SG-1 had a ten-year run, and it became my favorite TV show since Star Trek: TNG. Atlantis was also a great series until several key actors left.
What made SG-1, Atlantis, and TNG such great series was their morality and honor. Captain Picard (Patrick Stewart) had huge shoes to fill as captain of the Enterprise. While I personally have never been a fan of the original Star Trek, Captain Kirk was legendary. What made Captain Picard so great was that he didn’t try to fill Kirk’s shoes — he built a legacy of his own. Contrasting with Kirk, he was refined and thought out situations. He was honorable to a fault. Regardless of the situation, we always knew that Picard would take the high road and would stick to his principles like the Prime Directive. Remember the episode where he is captured by the Cardassians and would not bend to the torture to say there were five lights. The character of Picard was someone to look up to; in some part, he positively affected my formative teenage years.
Jack O’Neill and the rest of his team in SG-1 were also honorable. There were numerous episodes that showed their strong character. They always protected Earth. They held up their end of the bargains. They were out for the little guy. On another torture episode, O’Neill shows his character when he is captured by Baal. What an awesome hero.
Then in the decade of the 2000’s, TV started to change. Battlestar Galactica (the remake in the 2000’s) started good but had to show the “human side” of the characters. Rather than working as a team that exhibited the best of humanity, Galactica set characters against one another. And they always had sex with one another (which was shown in explicit detail even for TV). It only took about two episodes of Galactica to realize that it was not the role model of the past.
SG: Universe is written in the style of Galactica. In the last episode, not only was there a full sex scene, O’Neill pushed for something his character never would have. BTW, the sex scene alone was enough for me to turn it off. Are we really that low of losers that we have to watch others get thrills? Come on! Give us a strong story plot! Show us some honor and character in the show that make us want to be better. Writers, you don’t need to resort to cheap tricks to sell your work! I already know how low human beings can go; history is replete with it. When I turn on the TV, I want to see characters exceed their circumstances. I want to see them show honor in the face of opposition.
Sure, the leader in SG: Universe showed some character in the last episode. Dr. Rush did as well. But they also showed many weaknesses to date that I really don’t want to know. There are too many unknowns with them, which I know is intentional on the part of the writers. It seems that Hollywood doesn’t feel it’s being honest if it doesn’t show ALL sides of the characters. I certainly don’t want a “Leave it to Beaver” experience when I watch TV. But I also don’t want to see all the bad a person can think or do any more than I want to see my neighbors hang their troubles out for all to see. I want to see human beings work as a team, exhibit strong morals, and give me hope for the bright future of humanity.
I guess I’ll break out the old SG-1 or TNG DVDs to watch.
P.S. One of my other favorite shows of all time is the Firefly series. This one was made right when this transition to “humanity” was occurring. So while it was an awesome show with so much potential, it walked the line quite a bit as well. Galactica and Universe have walked right across it and off the cliff. It won’t be long before network television has all the rawness of an HBO miniseries. I’m sad for our prospects in Sci Fi these days.
P.P.S. The same thing has happened in books (especially Sci Fi books) in recent years.
P.P.P.S. I was just talking with my wife about this new “style” of shows, and she remarked that it is simply a new version of the soap opera. Pretty perceptive comment, IMO.